I recently posted a meme about the myth that autistic people lack empathy. I said that it is not true that we lack empathy and to say so was unhelpful and damaging. I got some interesting responses to this post including a few from autistic people saying they have low or no empathy. This got me thinking about my own experiences and has led to me feeling the need to unpack the idea of empathy and autism as it is possibly more complex than dismissing the experience of those who have low or no empathy.
When I was younger I always thought I had no empathy. I didn’t feel sad when other people were having a hard time. If someone died they were simply not in my life any more and I accepted that. I didn’t understand the consequences of my actions so while I didn’t want to hurt anyone if I did then I would not feel much remorse. However I also had the ability to take on the same emotions of those around me as if by osmosis. I now care immensely and want to ensure everyone I interact with is feeling happy and doing well. I worry about friends and am very sensitive to the moods of those around me.
All of this paints a picture of quite a complex experience of empathy. I am at once lacking in empathy, experience hyper empathy and experience what I would call practical empathy (empathy from a logical, ‘thinking’ perspective without an emotive component). I imagine that other autistic people share these experiences or their own versions of them.
One thing which always worried me was my struggle to grieve when anyone died. Death to me is inevitable and when someone does they are no longer in your life. There is no way of contacting the person and they exist in your memory. As a child and young adult I never grieved. I didn’t know what it meant to grieve. When someone left the world they left the world. I could not contact them so I got on with life without them. I just felt a bit sad and wished there was a phone to heaven so I could tell them about my day! Dr Wenn Lawson talks about the concept of object permanence and autism rather than people lacking empathy and I agree with him on this. While I miss a friend or relative who has passed they are no longer in my world and that is OK.
When I was younger I struggled with aggression. I was upset and regretted my actions but I didn’t feel anything emotive. The way I overcame violence was through practical, logical thought. I met some people who were victims of violence and I saw how it had affected them. I died not want to be responsible for anyone feeling that way so I stopped the aggressive behaviour. This is not empathy in the traditional sense. It is what I would call practical empathy. It also related to consequences. Understanding consequences was a major issue for me – maybe in a similar way to the object permanence issue I think. Once I had figured out what the consequences of my actions were and that they were negative I changed how I acted.
Empathy is a complex thing. It is not well understood. I think most autistic people that I have met have quite a lot of empathy of one sort or another. Even people who appear to lack empathy – like me in the past – may actually have quite a lot of it. It may seem that someone lacks empathy when in fact they express and experience it in different ways. I do think it is a harmful myth to say that autistic people lack empathy. The idea for this myth came from a clinician in the UK some years ago but it has remained a pervasive issue. It harms autistic people to be told we lack empathy – especially for people that have lots of it and those who experience it differently to others. This is another area where greater understanding about autism is essential.
In my own life it has been the case that I struggled with consequences for some years and with emotional empathy but that I also have a lot of the kind of empathy where I can pick up on the moods of others as if any osmosis and also in recent years that I have a lot of practical empathy. Practical empathy is where a person does kind things and supports others in practical ways rather than through an emotional connection. I have immense amounts of practical empathy. It drives my advocacy work and writing. So while I don’t grieve much when someone passes I do a whole range of things to demonstrate that I care for others. Empathy is more complicated than it is often portrayed. So there are some autistic people who are highly empathetic in different ways, some who are empathic in some ways and not others (like me) and some who have low or no empathy. This isn’t just for autistic people. Some neurotypical people also fit those descriptions. Levels and experiences of empathy are not right or wrong, they just are and that is OK and not a reason for criticism or judgement.










