Content warning: Bullying and violence
I recently read an article about Pathological Demand Avoidance (or PDA) and autism from the perspective of a parent who had done a lot of research to inform how they supported their child. It was a very interesting piece and I learned a new thing in it – the ‘fawn’ response. I have known about fight and flight as a response to threats for years and about the freeze response for a few less years but the fawn response was a new one on me. And it is a new piece of thinking which strongly resonated with my experience.
I have never done the fight response when under threat and rarely the flight one. I do the freeze one on occasion but I think up until recently at least, the fawn response has been my go to response to being threatened. The fawn response basically means a person tries to be pleasing to the thing – usually a person – threatening them. I think of it as the ‘too nice’ response whereby you placate the person posing the threat in order to (hopefully) escape unharmed.
When I was younger I did it all the time. I was afraid of confrontation as well as actual threats like violence and bullying. What I did was try to make myself as appealing as possible to the person threatening me. I think my subconscious figured if they liked me they would be less likely to damage me. Sadly it didn’t work like that and just resulted in me being seen as a complete victim and yes, indeed it led to me probably being victimised more than if I had used any of the other three responses to threat.
I hated that I became too nice when threatened. I felt like I had ‘victim’ written on my forehead in large red letters. I spent a significant period of time in prisons and locked psych wards in my early twenties. I was never physically assaulted in all that time. Not because I was scary myself, quite the opposite. I just ingratiated myself to every single person who I felt threatened by (i.e. everyone in there). I was absolutely terrified every minute of every day though. I learned how all the aggressive women liked their cuppa so they would appreciate my thoughtfulness. Most of my meagre pay went on cigarettes – not for me but for everyone else! While I may have added some years to my life from not smoking the cigarettes I bought, this approach especially came at the cost of my sense of self.
I was so keen to avoid threats by being nice that my sense of who I was was steadily eaten away. When I decided to change my life for the better when I was 25 I had no idea of who I was. The masking and being pathologically nice over the preceding years had left me with no idea of who I actually was. I did spend many years under constant threat. In prison your life is always at risk and things can change instantaneously in terms of relationships with fellow prisoners. As an autist who was noticeably ‘different’ and struggled to read facial expressions and other non-verbal cues, it was a very frightening place indeed.
The interesting thing is that in recent years I have stopped using the fawn response as a default. I remember being at an event a few years ago and there was a woman in attendance who I had distanced myself from as I found her threatening and we had a disagreement which has revealed her unpleasant side to me. She came up to me at lunch in front of several other people and demanded to speak to me. In an award-winning performance of assertiveness and limit-setting I said to her “You are a toxic person and I do not wish to speak with you.’ She walked off and I haven’t seen or heard of her since. When I said those words I was in fight, flight, freeze, fawn mode as it was pretty stressful and there was a risk of her being verbally aggressive. I don’t know which response I did – maybe fight? Not sure but it certainly wasn’t fawning.
I have become assertive and this impacts on how I respond when under pressure. I think my danger now is that I am possibly too assertive and set limits to strictly but I am aware of this so try to take that into consideration. For someone who felt like they had ‘victim’ written on their head for many years I can only conclude that this is a good problem to have!
I do think a lot of other autistic people have the fawn response as their default setting. I imagine it is influenced by some of things a lot of us experience – bullying and abuse and other invalidations. It could be seen as a safer response than fight, flight or freeze but if that becomes the default setting people can end up like I did not knowing who they are and being taken advantage of and victimised. The key for me was building my self-worth and my confidence. This did take some years but it is nice to be in a situation where I know if I am threatened or in a confrontation I am more likely to be able to control the situation and respond in a way which doesn’t result in me being further taken advantage of.
I wish I didn’t need to write this post. I hate that there are some people in the world who see a vulnerable person and think of ways to attack them. I hate that I was victimised for many years and that so many of my autistic siblings are still being victimised. I would never blame the victim for the abuse and bullying. I do know from my experience it is possible to respond to threatening situations with assertiveness and confidence. I wish that understanding for everyone as I know it makes life less frightening.










