This is a question with a few different answers – depending on your politics!
I was diagnosed as autistic in 1994. Back then it was called Asperger Syndrome. The clinician – a clinical psychiatrist – said that I fulfilled ‘all the diagnostic criteria for a diagnosis of Asperger Syndrome’. I was officially autistic. I didn’t accept the diagnosis for another seven years. Part of that was because I thought it was a disability and I really didn’t want one of those!
Since then I have gone from being in major denial to being one of the most visible autistic advocates in the world. I did end up accepting the inevitable, writing a book and I guess the rest is history. But that doesn’t answer the question. Do I think autism is a disability?
Autism is listed in a publication you may have heard of called the DSM 5. This book lists a whole load of mental illness conditions and neurological conditions. The DSM 5 is used by clinicians around the world to diagnose brain-related ‘things.’ Autistic people gaining a diagnosis – at least in some countries – get the diagnostic criteria from this book. Having a diagnosis of autism is technically a disability. But is it actually one?
I view my autism as an attribute – like my ability to write well, my capacity for love, fairness and kindness or my liking cats – possibly more than is healthy! I do not view my autism as a disability because the disabling aspects of autism – at least in my experience – are almost entirely due to the rest of the world not being very autism friendly! Given loud music or stinky smells can put me in a very stressful sensory place but these are only an issue when others don’t want to accommodate my needs. The workplace can be a positive or a negative experience for me but this tends to be due to the attitudes of my managers and colleagues and their understanding of autism rather than my autism itself. It is actually friarly easy to accommodate my needs. As such, the level of disablement due to my autism is largely related to the environment I am in.
My schizophrenia on the other hand, is disabling in and of itself. If I am unwell with schizophrenia the external environment has a far lesser impact on my wellbeing than my autism. Being psychotic in hospital or psychotic at home is mostly quite similar in terms of how disabled I am.
These observations are based on something called the social model of disability. This looks at disability as being largely caused by society. For example, if almost everyone in the world was a wheelchair user, someone who walked would be in a disabled position as they would be walking into doorframes and bending over all the time. In a similar way, if everyone in the world was autistic, a neurotypical person would be disabled.
The thing that gets me is that in order to access supports and funding, people need to demonstrate how disabled thy are. You get parents who have been raising their autistic kids to be proud of who they are and then they go into a funding meeting and ned to outline all the difficulties and challenges their kid has due apparently to their autism. This is very confusing for the kids and upsetting for the parents. It is hard to be empowered when you then need to go and prove how disabled you are! I think the long term solution to this issue is to remove the barriers and challenges for autistic people – and other neurodivergent people as well. This would mean we could shine and be our very own amazing autistic selves and not need to justify our existence by discussing our deficits and challenges. And while that possibly sounds like a pipe dream, I actually think it is possible.










