A couple of weeks ago autistic advocate Louis Brunel stood up at a conference and made a clear and powerful statement against the father of anti-vax, Andrew Wakefield, who used to be Dr Andrew Wakefield but was deregistered as a doctor after publishing a paper linking autism to vaccines using incorrect ‘evidence’ and then manufacturing a ‘movement’. Louis Brunel became my instant hero for doing this and it got me thinking about the issues with fear-mongering about autism.
Wakefield sparked off a whole load of pseudo scientific nonsense which fed existing negative views and is extremely damaging to autistic people and those who love and care for us. I want to unpack these views and their associated ‘movement’. I wish I didn’t have too but tragically this stuff still carries weight among many of the population.
The first myth I want to bust is that of the ‘autism epidemic’. I am definitely not the first person to do this. The idea of autism as an ‘epidemic’ revolves around lot of meaningless correlation of statistics. Correlation does not equal causation as any first year PhD candidate could tell you but this hasn’t stopped this myth taking hold. Apparently the MMR vaccine and a growth in autism diagnoses were related to each other. You could just as easily connect the decline in people using cassette tapes with increases in autism rates if both occurred at the same time but correlation and causation are entirely different things. Something happening at the same time doesn’t mean one causes the other. Sensible researchers and Autistic advocates and our allies have more reasonably seen the increase in autism diagnoses as being the result of greater awareness of autism by clinicians and the public leading to higher rates of diagnosis. The idea of an ‘epidemic’ is in itself highly problematic. Firstly autism isn’t a disease. You cannot ‘catch autism’. And the negativity inherent in talking about epidemics is all extremely problematic and extremely disrespectful to autistic people. This kind of fear-mongering hurts autistic people and does not help anyone. Mental illness diagnosis rates have increased dramatically in recent years as well but there is no ‘movement’ saying what a tragedy this is and finding some spurious reason for it. Lifetime prevalence of mental illness in Australia is one in two people. That is way more than the one in 70 or so who are autistic but nobody is going around scare-mongering about that!
In terms of evidence, anti-vax has been disproven hundreds of times by reputable studies. Despite this it still holds sway with some people. It has been consistently refuted by genuine scientific researchers in peer reviewed studies over the years. There is no real scientific evidence that vaccines have anything to do with autism but it persists. The very fact I am writing this is testament to the influence it has.
At its heart all of this problematic thinking has a view that autism is a tragedy and autistic people have no worthwhile views or thoughts. It goes to eugenics and has spawned a number of other ‘movements’ including the ‘bleach enemas cure autism’ horror. It goes against everything I believe and promote as an Autistic advocate. On my social media I am pretty open to different views but anti-vax viewpoints will result in me removing that person from my social media. I feel like the views are the enemy of autistic people and attack anything positive. They drag the whole discussion into an unhelpful place where advocates need to justify our existence and we have been doing that for a long time and it is not a good thing.
The other major issue with these views is that they influence people new to the world of autism. Parents of a newly diagnosed child might be exposed to this thinking and it will colour their view of their child. I often view these issues as being like a war between reason and misinformation. It is sadly not a struggle we can give up because if we do then we lose ground and more people are influenced by this awful, harmful, negative thinking. It is dangerous. I recently unfriended a Facebook follower who said they thought Wakefield might have answers to their questions. He doesn’t have any useful answers, just scaremongering and hatred. We need to stand up to this stuff where we can. I am thinking this article may well result in some trolling as the anti-vaxers are pretty vocal in silencing criticism but I am doing this because I feel I need to. Addressing this stuff in any way we can is going to be helpful. I am inspired by Louis Brunel’s speech. I don’t think I could be that brave to face Wakefield and challenge him but I can write this. When I said I was going to write this post one of my Facebook family, Ian W, said “Fear is not moving us forward… Hope is.” Which to me is a fitting summary of this post and of the work which needs doing in this area.










